Girardi Tipping His Hand On DH Matter

("Hmmmm, Damon or Matsui?  Damon or Matsui?")

While making at appearance at the Modell's in Times Square yesterday, Joe Girardi shed some insight on where his preferences may lie for a left-handed DH.

"When you think about Raul Ibanez, he has had success wherever he has [gone]... "

"Obviously, we know what Johnny and Matty [Matsui] have meant to this organization over the years, and how they've been successful in New York.  I'm curious to see how it is all going to shake out."

"I can't tell you it is going to be one of those three guys, or anyone. But obviously, we know they know how to play here."

Well we know Joe likes his veterans, so this is really no surprise that he wouldn't mind having one of the 3 guys he's most familiar with and he thinks are most familiar with Yankee Stadium.  But how good are these 3 as potential fillers of that lefty DH spot?

Ibanez was pretty awful in 2011 (.245/.289/.419, .306 wOBA, -1.3 WAR in 575 PA), but was better against righties (.256/.307/.440, .322 wOBA), making him an obvious platoon candidate.  But even those positive splits aren't much to write home about, and Ibanez is old as fuck and basically useless as an emergency option to play the field.  Not a lot to like here.

Damon was actually productive at the plate last season (.261/.326/.418, .328 wOBA in .647 PA) and it's likely those numbers would play up a bit more hitting in Yankee Stadium, a place Damon really learned how to tailor his lefty swing to in order to generate some good power numbers.  But as a platoon DH candidate, Damon might not fit the Yankees' needs, indicated by his reverse vs. L/vs. R splits in 2011 (.812 OPS, .355 wOBA vs. L, .715 OPS, .313 wOBA vs. R).

Matsui, who is younger than Damon, might actually be the most shot out of any of these 3.  He hit just .251/.321/.375 in 2011, and his reverse splits vs. right-handed and left-handed pitching is even more severe than Damon's (just a .291 wOBA vs. RH).  Matsui is also practically incapable of playing the field, something that Damon can still do if needed.

Out of these 3, I think Damon's ability to still play the field and run the bases at a respectable level tips the odds in his favor, and he should bounce back a bit against righties hitting towards the short porch in right.  But I'm not sure I would say I'm as big a fan of any of these 3 as primary options for the DH spot as Joe seems to be.