The Yankees and Tigers met 7 times in the regular season, first in the season opening series at the end of March/beginning of April and then in early May, with the Tigers taking 4 of the 7 games. In the months since then, a lot of things have changed about each team, but many things have stayed the same. There will be a few new faces on either side that weren't present in the spring, but the core of each team remains intact. A basic once over of each team reveals more similarities than differences.
Both teams boast strong, deep lineups that were among the best in baseball all season (Yankees
.346 wOBA- 3rd in MLB; Tigers
.336- 4th. Both teams in top 5 in wRC+), and both have rotations with strength at the top and then question marks behind that (CC-Nova for the Yanks, Verlander-Fister for the Tigers). Both teams can hit, and both teams can pitch (kinda), so there won't be an easy predictors for determining victory at the basic level, AKA the Tim McCarver Method of Analyzing Baseball. Luckily, I've already done a little digging to find the 3 keys to this series.
1) Speed/Athleticism
Something that typically gets overlooked in baseball decisions, and something I admittedly rarely consider when breaking down matchups, but there are some stats tied to this that the Yanks and Tigers are not even close in, and it will play a factor. First, defensively the Yankees boast a team Fielding Rating of
22.9, good for 7th in MLB. The Tigers team rating is
-2.0, which puts them near the bottom. The Yankees are boosted by strong ratings for Brett Gardner in left and Nick Swisher in right, as well as Martin behind the plate, Teix at first, and A-Rod at third, and even Jeter, Cano, and C-Grand pass the eye test at their respective positions more often than not. The Tigers, however, are a bit of a mess in the field. There's nobody close to a Gold Glover in the infield, and even the speed of Austin Jackson can't cover for the limitations of the lumbering Delmon Young in left and Magglio Ordonez in right. Quite simply, the Yankees get to more balls and make more plays in the field than the Tigers do.
The other area where the Yanks' athleticism advantage should show through is on the basepaths. The Yankees' team Baserunning Rating of
1.1 only puts them in the middle of the pack amongst MLB teams, but the Tigers' rating of
-7.6 ranks 26th. And there's also the wide gap in stolen bases to consider. New York's
147 SB was 4th in baseball; Detroit's
49 was dead last. We've seen the Yankees go for the steal, double steal, hit-and-run, and sac bunt often this season, using their speed and baserunning skills to their advantage. We won't see any of that from the Tigers.
It's a small part of the game, something that can't be as easily measure statistically as other things, but those numbers show that the Yankees have a decided advantage in the Speed/Athleticism department. Their defense gets a boost from it, allowing them to better pick up their pitchers when the ball is in play, and their offense becomes more dynamic and more versatile as a result of their speed on the basepaths. In a short series it will be next to impossible to quantify this, but we've all seen how just a couple of plays here and there can change a series: a diving catch here, a stolen base or extra base taken on a ball in the gap there. The Yankees are much more equipped to take advantage of those opportunities than the Tigers are and I expect them to continue to use that to their advantage every chance they get.