As mentioned earlier today on the AB4AR Page, Joel Sherman reported that Ichiro Suzuki enjoyed his time as a Yankee after the trade this season and that Ichiro "strongly wants to stay" with New York next season. Without delving too deeply into this, allow me to make my case against this idea.
Average age of Yankee postseason roster- 33.08 years
Current Age of Ichiro- 39 years
It just doesn't make any sense to make an already old team with a ton of money tied up in its oldest players any older. Ichiro did exactly what the Yankees wanted him to do and exactly what a lot of people thought he would do after the Yankees traded for him. But that still doesn't change the fact that he has deteriorated significantly as a player himself in the past 2 seasons, and the odds of him replicating what he did in his short time with the Yankees over a full season next year are incredibly low. Let him be what he was and go out on a positive as a Yankee and focus efforts on finding a younger, more versatile outfield solution.
Thursday, October 25, 2012
(Not pictured: Brett Gardner and his elbow. Courtesy of the AP)
The start of the AB4AR 2012 Season Review officially kicked off yesterday with the review of what we learned about the 2012 infield. It continues today with that same review for the outfield. The starting outfield for the 2012 New York Yankees was an interesting mix. 3 guys with very different but equally important skill sets who combined to be one of the most productive and underappreciated units in baseball in 2011, and 3 guys whose futures with the club were all potentially up in the air in the near future. As with the infield, it was a big up-and-down year for this crew, so let's dive right in and see what 2012 taught us about them.
(Hey! Nunez in the outfield was fun, huh? Courtesy of the AP)
Eduardo Nunez is a strange case. He reminds me of a joke that Patrice O'Neal told about Jeff Ross at one of the Comedy Central Roasts, where he called Ross a legend and then corrected himself by saying Ross was more like a myth because everybody had heard stories about how funny he is, "but nobody's ever really seen it." That's Eduardo Nunez to me; he's been talked about as the next big homegrown position player piece for the future for what seems like the last 3-4 years, and he always ends up not being that. I bring this up today because Cash and Joe each mentioned Nunez in their recent year-end addresses, but not in a way that makes his current or future standing within the organization any more clear than it's ever been. To me, it almost seems like the Yankees have no clue what to do with Nunez anymore, and if that's the case then it might be time to trade him.