(Happy Mark Buehrle is happy. Courtesy of The AP)
At this point, we've moved from the #2-type starters down to the #3s. First up, Mark "Curl of The" Buehrle.
(A Mastodon reference and Chris Berman joke in the same sentence. Score!)
- Consistency, consistency, consistency. Buehrle is frighteningly consistent. He's made at least 30 starts every year since his first full MLB season in 2001, thrown at least 201.0 innings every season since '01, and has won at least 10 games every season since '01 (at least 13 in 9 out of the 11 seasons). To call the guy a workhorse would be an understatement.
- Durability, durability, durability. Buehrle couldn't have put up that consistent level of production without being healthy. He's never missed a significant amount of time due to injury, so his track record suggests that he would come with very low health-related risks despite the workload.
- His performance over these past 11 seasons has been above average. Career 3.83 ERA, career 4.13 FIP, and 2 consecutive seasons of a FIP below 4.00. He's also produced at least 3.4 WAR in all but one of his seasons. The only Yankee starter to produce more than that last year was CC.
- Like Oswalt, Buehrle likes to work fast and throw strikes. He generates a lot of swings and contact, but most of it is the weak type of contact he wants off of the cutter or changeup, his 2 best pitches. Also like Oswalt, Buehrle has tremendous command. His career BB/9 is just 2.05 and he's been at least 2.14 or lower in BB/9 every season since 2004.
- Dude can field his position like a boss. 3 straight Gold Gloves and the inspiration for the "Buehrle-Meter" on BBTN.
- Stuff-wise Buehrle isn't much. His average fastball velocity in 2011 was just 85.6 MPH and it's trending downward as he gets into his 30s. The value of his fastball dropped from slightly above average in 2010 to 12.5 runs below average this past season, suggesting poor future results for him on the pitch he uses to set up his 2 out pitches.
- Because of the soft fastball and the fact that he pitches to contact, Buehrle's K rates aren't very good. Career K/9 is 5.07 but he hasn't had a season with a K/9 above 5.00 since 2008. Bill James projects a slight rebound in that category for 2012, but fewer Ks means more balls in play, and that could mean more balls pulled through the left side against Jeter and The Horse.
- Although he isn't as old as Oswalt, but at 32 Buehrle is approaching the downside of his career. And while he hasn't gotten hurt yet, all that mileage on his arm over the last 10 years could just mean he's ready to break down as he approaches his mid-30s.
- Recently Buerhle hasn't been very good at the beginning or the end of seasons. It's admittedly a bit of a nitpick, but for a team that's always going to be in the playoff hunt, the Yankees can't afford to have starters bombing in September and October.
The Yankees could certainly do worse than adding Buehrle to the 2012 rotation. He would be the 2nd lefty that they haven't had since Pettitte retired, which would be nice to break up the righties. But at his age with his stuff, Buehrle does not fit the top-of-the-rotation mold that the Yankees are looking for. Combined with Nova, he could provide a solid stable of #3-#4-type pitchers behind CC if Hughes and A.J. can bounce back in 2012, and he also won't command nearly the dollars or years that Wilson or Darvish will. You know you're going to get innings and above-average production from Buehrle, but odds are he will be looked at as more of a contingency plan for the Yankees in case they don't get one of the higher-upside guys.